Best Pizza Places in Gainesville, FL

When it comes to satisfying your pizza cravings, Gainesville, FL, offers a diverse range of local pizzerias that are sure to hit the spot. From old-school classics to unique and innovative pies, this beautiful city has something for every pizza lover.

satchel's pizza
Todd Van Hoosear, CC BY-SA 2.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Whether you’re in the mood for a thin-crust, Neapolitan-style masterpiece, a mouthwatering deep-dish indulgence, or a slice with an unforgettable twist, Gainesville has got you covered. The city’s diverse culinary scene promises a memorable pizza experience, suitable for cozy family dinners, lively friend gatherings, or simply indulging in a delicious slice after a long day.

Here, we’ve compiled a list of the 15 best pizza places in Gainesville, FL, to help you navigate the vast selection of eateries and discover your own personal favorites. Let’s dive into the world of Gainesville’s most tantalizing pizza spots and get ready to satisfy your taste buds!

Top 5 Must-Try Pizza Places

Satchel’s Pizza

With a unique and eclectic atmosphere, Satchel’s Pizza stands out as a must-try pizza destination in Gainesville. Known for its delicious, homemade pizza dough and wide variety of toppings, Satchel’s is a local favorite.

Aside from their pizza, their salad is the second most famous menu item. Fresh greens, with carrots, cucumbers, sliced tomatoes, apples, nuts and homemade balsamic vinaigrette is truly delicious. Their slice and salad lunch special is a fantastic deal!

The quirky outdoor dining area offers a fun and vibrant setting for customers to enjoy their yummy slices and pints.

Piesano’s Stone Fired Pizza

Piesano’s Stone Fired Pizza offers a taste of Italy right in Gainesville with their mouthwatering, stone-fired pizzas. With a diverse menu selection, Piesano’s caters to both traditional and inventive pizza lovers, and has also earned a reputation for its delectable garlic knots.

While we may be showcasing pizza, their wings and meatball subs are absolutely delicious. And if you love dipping your pizza in ranch dressing, their homemade ranch dressing is the best in town.

Blue Highway a Pizzeria

Famous for their hand-tossed, thin-crust pizza, Blue Highway a Pizzeria is a Gainesville local favorite. With high-quality ingredients and a commitment to freshness, this pizzeria is perfect for those seeking an authentic New York-style pizza experience.

The casual dining atmosphere and friendly service only enhance the delicious pie experience. The original Blue Highway is located in Micanopy, while their second location is in the Town of Tioga.

Pomodoro Cafe

At Pomodoro Cafe, guests will enjoy a cozy and inviting atmosphere while indulging in their scrumptious pizzas. Offering a wide variety of toppings and crust options, Pomodoro Cafe is sure to satisfy any pizza craving.

Beyond the pizza menu, guests can also enjoy an array of Italian dishes and desserts. Plus, they have a great BOGODORO or Buy One Get One on select pizzas, pastas, and subs.

Did you know we serve BOGO all day every day? Our Bogodoro special is 2-for-1 takeout on select pizzas, pastas, and subs. Call 352-380-9886 to order today!

Posted by Pomodoro Café on Wednesday, January 11, 2023

Leonardo’s Pizza

Leonardo’s Pizza is a Gainesville institution since 1976, known for its famous garlic rolls. The large Chicago style slices, unique topping combinations, and welcoming atmosphere make Leonardo’s a popular spot for hungry pizza lovers.

A diverse selection of beers, wines, and refreshing cocktails will complement your pizza feast perfectly. Their Dinner for two weekly special is a great place to share a pie with a loved one.

Great Options for Different Cravings

Best Thin Crust

When it comes to thin crust pizza in Gainesville, V Pizza and Side Car tops the list as a local favorite. Their handcrafted pies bake quickly in a high-temperature brick oven, ensuring a crispy, delicious crust. Customize your pizza with a variety of fresh toppings and sauces to suit your taste buds.

Best Deep Dish

For those who love a hearty deep dish pizza, you can beat Satch Squared or Leonardo’s.

Satch Squared is a Detroit style pizza, thick square crust, lots of cheese and a light sauce on top. Their thick, buttery crust and generous layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings make for an indulgent, satisfying meal, perfect for sharing. Their veggie pizza is my favorite!

Leonardo’s of Millhopper Chicago style pizza, the Big Leo, has been one of the best deep dish pizzas in Gainesville for over 45 years. Don’t leave without trying the garlic rolls!

Best Vegan and Vegetarian

Satchel’s Pizza is a go-to spot for vegan and vegetarian pizza options. With various plant-based cheeses and an abundance of vegetable toppings, Satchel’s makes it easy to create a flavorful, meat-free pizza that doesn’t skimp on taste.

Best Gluten-Free

For those seeking a gluten-free pizza option, O Sole Mio Cucina Italiana offers a delicious, gluten-free crust that ensures everyone can enjoy their Italian-inspired pies. Topped with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection, this is a must-try for those with dietary restrictions.

Best Late-Night Pizza

Craving pizza after a night out? Look no further than Gumby’s Pizza or Five Star Pizza. Both have been institutions in Gainesville since the mid 1980s and favorites with students with late night cravings. With convenient locations around Gainesville and late-night delivery options till 3 am.

Local Favorites to Explore

Gainesville, Florida is home to several delicious pizza places that are popular among the locals. In this section, we present our other local favorites not mentioned above, for you to explore.

Italian Gator Pizza by the Slice is a go-to spot for a quick and delicious slice of pizza. The generous portions and wide variety of toppings make it a perfect destination for lunch or dinner.

I Love NY Pizza is a family-owned and operated restaurant that serves up authentic New York-style pizza and delicious Italian entrees. All of their ingredients are fresh and high quality, making sure you get the best meal possible. They offer a variety of classic pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and other Italian favorites.

Scuola Pizza is an Italian restaurant that brings a modern twist to traditional Italian cuisine. From classic pizzas to seasonal specials, they offer something for everyone. Plus they also have vegetarian and vegan options, as well as a wide selection of craft beer.

Peppino’s Pizza and Pasta may be new to Gainesville, but the owner Joe has been creating NY style pizzas for 17+ years. Not only are their pies delicious, but their chicken wings and Tiramisu were equally flavorful.

Humble Wood Fire Pizza brings the authentic wood-fired pizza experience right to your table. With made-from-scratch dough, premium San Marzano tomatoes and all natural ingredients, Humble creates the ultimate pizza with a perfect blend of flavors, textures and aromas.

Other Favorite Pizza Shops

While we focus on locally established pizza shops, there are a few local franchise pizza joints worth visiting.

Blaze Pizza is the go-to spot for delicious and healthy pizza. Choose from a variety of specialty pizzas or create your own with their made-from-scratch doughs, house-made sauces, fresh vegetables and meats. They also offer vegan and gluten free options to accommodate all dietary needs.

Midici Pizza brings Italy’s authentic Neapolitan pizzas to the US. All their pizzas are made with hand stretched dough, San Marzano tomatoes and all natural ingredients. You can choose from their signature pies or make your own to satisfy your cravings.

Conclusion

In summary, Gainesville, Florida is home to a diverse range of pizzerias offering delicious pizza options for every taste. From classic Italian-style to New York-style and even Greek-inspired flavors, you won’t run out of options to try. Besides enjoying the various takes on pizza, patrons can also appreciate the unique atmosphere each venue offers.

While our list has covered some of the most delicious pizza in Gainesville, there are still many pizzerias out there waiting to be discovered.

author avatar
Jena Slocum

Leave a Comment